As the Raptor Lake crashing CPU debacle rumbles on, maybe AMD's latest Ryzen 9000-series processors suffer from the same or at least a similar problem with spiking voltages causing CPU instability and even death? That's what YouTube channel Tech YES City is claiming.
In testing, Tech YES City found that ASRock motherboards tended to use less power and run lower voltages, both under load and at idle, compared to motherboards from the likes of MSI and Asus. [[link]] And the differences are occasionally substantial.
By way of example, an ASRock B850 board running a Ryzen 9 9950X was found to consume a peak of 39 W and an average of 33 W when playing a video file, while an MSI X870E hit 58 W and 40 W by the same metrics.
Similarly, the maximum EDC amperage during gaming was found to be 77 A for the ASRock board and 92 A for the MSI board. Those kinds of deltas seem [[link]] to be consistent throughout.
But wait, lower power and voltage should be safer, right? Well, yes, but not if that's on average and yet when you look at the fine detail you're getting lower voltages most of the time punctuated by severe micro-spikes.
Tech YES City observed the SoC voltage on all of the boards at default settings. The ASRock boards were found to exhibit dynamic voltage—ie voltage that varies—while the other boards were static or very, very nearly static.
The reason to have dynamic votlage is to save power by lowering the average voltage. But according to Tech YES City, that could introduce the possibility of voltage spikes.
"Perhaps with the Ryzen 9000 Series," Tech YES City says, "there's some sort of request going on that's causing this very minuscule—it might be microseconds or milliseconds—where it's requesting so much voltage, and that's just killing the CPU."
If that's correct, what's the solution? Again, according to Tech YES City if you tick enable for ''SoC OC mode" (also sometimes known as "uncore OC mode")in the motherboard BIOS, the SoC voltage will remain static.
It's unclear why that's the case, you might think an OC mode would push settings harder, not cap them. But perhaps that setting simply sets a higher static voltage, preventing any spikes.
Moreover, all of this is at least a little familiar in the context of a similar voltage spike issue that hit the Ryzen 7000 series was patched back in 2023.
Anywho, it will be interesting to see how this one develops. Tech YES City say they have reached out to ASRock but have yet to hear back. But the channel also says that despite the fact that the problem seems more prevalent on ASRock boards, it's ultimately an issue with the CPU, not the motherboard. It just somewhat hinges on motherboard settings for exposure.
An official comment from AMD would also be nice. Watch this space for more.
